| Case 9: Tank Cave |
|
|
Reprinted from Cave Divers Association of Australia (CDAA) Report, 2012 The victim (aged 40) had been a CDAA diver for 10 years, diving in Tank Cave for 5 years. The victim, however, had not dived in this cave site for 11 months and his buddy also lacked recent Tank Cave experience. On the weekend of October 15-16 in 2011, the victim and his buddy did two uneventful dives in Tank Cave on the Saturday, including one long stage dive. On Sunday morning they planned a long stage dive to the GS section of Tank Cave, but the arrival of another diver made them change their plans and do a smaller dive with him instead. In order to “gas match” with the new arrival, they used their 100cuft steels for this shorter dive, leaving their smaller set of cylinders and a small stage for the longer second dive. Hence for the second dive, the victim and his buddy both used 85cuft steels as primary cylinders, but the victim carried a smaller stage tank (65cuft vs 80cuft). The victim was a much larger man than his buddy. There was no discussion about gas planning before the dive. They set off for the GS section of the cave, both placing personal markers at every T-junction and placing jump reels where required. At H3 (over half way into the dive), both divers dropped their stage tanks and continued. As they approached the slight restriction at GS2, the victim was behind his buddy. The buddy swam through the restriction and continued to the end of the tunnel approximately 50m further on. When he reached the end, the buddy turned to see that the victim was not with him. The buddy returned to GS2 (approximately five minutes later) to find the victim was not there. The buddy continued out of the cave, noting some disturbances in the silt between GS2 and GS1. Continuing out, he did not see the victim again but noted that the personal markers and the stage tank had been removed, indicating that the victim was ahead. On reaching the "short cut", the buddy found one of the victim’s markers on the floor of the cave. At SC1 the marker was still on the line. Another marker was still present on the line at A3. Between A2 and A1 a hand held torch was lying on the floor of the cave, still switched on. The buddy surfaced after completing 30 minutes of decompression to be told the victim was not on the surface. The buddy returned to the cave (still with 70bar in each of his 3 cylinders) and located the victim just off the line adjacent to A1, floating dead on the ceiling. He had presumably swum beneath the victim when he first exited the cave. The deceased was approximately 25m from the entrance, and had 3 completely empty cylinders. It may remain unknown exactly what happened to the victim to make him exit from GS2 without awaiting the buddy’s return. It may be that he recognised that his gas reserves were low and felt he could not afford to wait. It is possible that he suffered some medical mishap, however there was no evidence for this. There was no sign of any equipment malfunction. It was observed by the recovery team that the deceased was very positively buoyant with the 3 empty cylinders attached. If his positive buoyancy worsened during the exit, this would have contributed to his excessive gas consumption. Accident Analysis
|


